7 Unconventional Shoe Styles You Can Easily Thrift Online
You know that fashion girlie we all follow who’s always rocking a rare pair of shoes you’ve never seen anyone else style? Yeah, they’re probably thrifted. Now, secondhand shoe shopping might be one of the most controversial corners of the preloved world, but here at Sustainable Baddie, we’re firm believers that for every pair of thrifted shoes that fall apart, there’s a gem waiting to be discovered.
One of the best ways to find the styles from brands we love is to go secondhand. Some of the shoes on this list are from brands whose older designs aren’t available anymore but can be easily found on the secondhand market, while others are styles that are tricky to find anywhere aside from online marketplaces. This list pulls together a mix of designs we’re nostalgic for and others that are timeless, a little weird, and perfect for adding something unexpected to your shoe rotation.
1. Vintage Fluevogs
Fluevog shoes have been a staple of the quirky, weird, maximalists since they started in the ‘70s. Over the years, they've stayed true to their Art Deco roots while evolving to include more contemporary styles that still exude that signature eccentricity.
To find them secondhand, search: “Fluevog vintage,” “Fluevog boots,” “rare Fluevog,” or ”Fluevog collectors edition.”
2. Z-Coil Shoes
Some of the coolest shoes are…orthopedic? Z-Coil shoes were created in 1995 and designed with a spring coil under the heel to reduce impact on the joints. Today, you might find them on the foot of a creaky 25-year-old who thinks they’re comfy and a bit ironic.
To find them secondhand, search: “z-coil shoes” “vintage z-coil,” or “Z-coil spring shoes”
3. Yeti/Fur Boots
My favorite part of indie sleaze revival just might be furry shoes. Fur-lined, oversized, and often a little extra, Yeti boots are destined to turn heads. I especially love to see them worn with shorts (we love a good contrast in an outfit). And if you’re not ready to commit to a whole new shoe, I recently found a pair of fur leg warmers that turn any shoe into a Yeti boot.
To find them secondhand, search: “fur Yeti boots,” “vintage fur-lined boots,” “fur leg warmers,” or “vintage leg warmers.”
4. Spiked Shoes
Remember Jeffrey Campbell’s iconic spiked Litas from the 2010s? They’re already making a comeback. You don't have to go for a heel either—if you're after something more comfortable, spiked loafers and Mary Janes are out there on your favorite secondhand app, just waiting to go home with you.
To find them secondhand, search: “spiked shoes,” “Jeffrey Campbell Litas,” or “punk spiked boots.”
5. Boxer Shoes
Boxer shoes have been dominating my Pinterest style board for the past year. They’re perfect for adding a little muscle to your look. But if you’re not feeling the boxer shoe vibe, athletic-inspired flats, and sneakers will still give you that effortlessly cool, sporty edge you’re looking for.
To find them secondhand, search: “Boxer shoes,” “chunky athletic shoes,” or “vintage sporty shoes.”
6. Sneaker Heels/Wedges
The '90s and early 2000s were all about blending athletic and glam, giving birth to the trend of sneaker heels and wedges. While you can definitely find a pair of vintage Isabel Marant sneaker heels, there are also plenty of lesser-known styles out there that offer the same look at a much more affordable price.
To find them secondhand, search: “sneaker heels,” “wedge sneakers,” or “Isabel Marant sneaker wedges.”
7. Edwardian Boots
For the girlies who love a touch of whimsy and historical flair, Edwardian boots are a must-have in your closet. Their intricate lacing, pointed toes, and stacked heels create a form-fitting yet antique-inspired layer to any outfit.
To find them secondhand, search: “Edwardian boots,” “vintage lace-up boots,” or “Victorian boots.”
What’s your favorite unconventional shoe design?